Deep ocean lure grows as high-tech drilling pays off

08 15, 2012 by Reuters

  • Ultra-deep water accounts for half of all 2012 oil finds
  • Plans to go deeper yet, testing engineers' ingenuity
  • 80 rigs now on contract with 7,500 feet depth capability

Booming like never before, the offshore oil and gas industry is exploring ever deeper into the ocean and drilling further under the sea bed, bringing strikes like one this week off Brazil that may be one of the biggest yet in the region.

"Ultra-deep" wells, drilled in water at least 1.5 km (4,500 feet) deep into several more kilometres of rock to the reservoir below, have reached a landmark in 2012 to date, accounting for more than half of all the world's new discoveries so far this year, data from IHS Offshore Rig Consulting shows.

And from a global fleet of over 1,200 rigs and drilling vessels tracked by, more than 80 rigs on contract now have the ability to work in ocean depths of more than 7,500 feet. That compares to fewer than 10 at the turn of the century and double the number at work just two years ago, IHS says.

It is not hard to see where the funds are coming from: the world's biggest offshore oil players, from the likes of BP , Royal Dutch/Shell and Chevron to national oil companies with promising offshore waters such as Petrobras in Brazil, India's ONGC and Mexico's Pemex - are using the proceeds of high oil prices to spend at a pace.

Petrobras's new Carcara strike was 2 km below the surface of the Atlantic in an area causing much excitement.

Data from analysts at Wood Mackenzie puts total exploration spending among the Western oil majors alone at over $80 billion this year, more than four times the level in 2002 - and up 25 percent compared to 2010. Much of that is going offshore, and the results are coming thicker and faster than many expected.

As well as the news from Brazil, this week also saw unexpectedly strong results announced by Norwegian oil services company Aker Solutions, an offshore specialist.

"The market seems better than anyone had hoped," said Christian Frederik Lunde, an analyst at brokerage Carnegie.

The factors driving private oil and gas companies into the ocean have been around for decades; resource nationalism denies them access to three quarters of the world's known reserves, the economics and politics of offshore development are simpler than on land, and the finds are big and economically viable.

A sustained period of high oil prices have pushed this latest boom, but technological breakthroughs have accelerated it, too.

This week's Brazilian breakthrough is an example. Drilled in 2,027 metres of water to a depth of 6,213 metres, the Carcara well is in a so-called subsalt field, underneath salt layers that once hid the hydrocarbon deposits from seismologists.

It was all so different 30 years ago, when the North Sea between Britain and Norway was still new exploration territory.

Engineers wondered then how they would ever drill from a sea bed deeper than a man could dive, and into reservoir pressures that would be higher than that diver's oxygen tank.

"We thought we were pretty amazing when we did it," recalls Eamonn O'Connell, a veteran of the pioneering era and now BP's director for well interventions and integrity.


Today, those achievements in 140 metres or 400-plus feet of water look like child's play beside wells in the deep oceans. The world's deepest offshore production well, operated by Shell from the Perdido platform in the U.S. Gulf, is 9,356 feet - almost three km - below the waves.

The water pressure alone at that depth is 4,500 pounds per square inch (psi), or 310 bar - similar to that inside those North Sea wells of the 1980s. The reservoirs themselves in the U.S. Gulf, off West Africa, Brazil and elsewhere, are several kilometres deeper again below the seabed, testing engineering ingenuity at pressures up to 18,000 psi -- more than three times what the North Sea geologists had to worry about.

The risks are great, as demonstrated by BP's Macondo well, of 2010 Gulf oil spill infamy. Drilled in just below 5,000 feet of water and encountering pressure of 12,000 psi, it was not a record breaker. Yet the Transocean -managed Deepwater Horizon rig exploded, killing 11 people. The pipework collapsed, buckling, and the blowout preventer failed.

A spewing, broken Macondo took months to cap, set off the United States' worst offshore environmental disaster, and is set to cost BP billions of dollars in compensation and fines. It also overshadows the financial future of Tra nsoce a n, t he wor ld's n umb er one rig operator.

But the potential rewards offshore are equally enormous.

Since 2002, WoodMac data shows, the average "shelf", or shallow offshore exploration, well has added 21 million barrels of oil equivalent (boe) in reserves, compared with just 12 million for the average conventional onshore well.

In deep water - defined as deeper than 1,200 feet - the average leaps to 55 million boe. IHS data maps the average ultra-deep find, 4,500 feet down, higher again - at 140 million.

That is 11.5 times more effective than an onshore rig, and at $100 a barrel, amounts to $14 billion worth of oil per discovery in the ultra-deep - enough to repay a whole year of capital spending for some of the world's top oil companies.

"It's not too surprising. The deeper you go, the bigger the reservoir you need to make drilling worthwhile," says IHS data analyst Tom Kellock. "The good news is, people are finding what they are looking for."


For all the potential foreseen for onshore shale techniques in the United States, there is nothing marginal about the importance of offshore oil and gas to future energy supplies.

On a production basis alone, WoodMac expects known deep and ultra-deep offshore finds to be producing twice what they are today in 10 years time, at 15 million boe of oil and gas a day. That is double last year's total U.S. oil output.

Thunder Horse in the U.S. Gulf is BP's flagship well for the ultra-deep generation. The company's Eamonn O'Connell kisses his fingertips in fond recollection of the quality of the 1999 discovery which eventually went into production in 2008.

The Thunder Horse platform is not in the deepest water, at 6,000 feet, but the wells it serves extend as much as 19,000 feet below the seabed and are among the deepest ever drilled, on- or offshore.

The well pressures range from 13,000 to 18,000 psi at temperatures up to 132 degrees Celsius (270 Fahrenheit) - right at the limit of current offshore capability.

They are not stopping here.

BP launched this year a project it calls 20K - aimed at the next generation of even deeper, higher pressure, higher temperature wells at pressures of more than 20,000 psi.

Supercomputers, new materials, coatings and sub-sea sensors are being developed to exploit oil at these depths, and platform designers are looking at basing more gear on the sea floor so that pressures can be reduced on the way to the surface.

Quite what will be possible is unclear. For the energy to be harnessed, engineers will have to get amazing again.